Cheese

Midwest Favorites

We are proud to be part of the Midwest and located near some of the nation’s top cheese producers! We offer a large variety of cheeses, so you always find exactly what you are looking for.

We carry one of Sheboygan’s largest selections of local and Wisconsin cheeses in our store. Come in and choose from over 100 varieties!

Cheese on a cutting board

Cheese

Now also offering Cady Creek, Kindred Creamery, Meister and Nordic Creamery.

Laack's

  • Regular & flavored Curds
  • Mozzarella Whips
  • Regular, Smoked, and Pepper String
  • Pepper Jack
  • Vegetable Jack
  • 4, 6, 8, & 12 year Sharp Cheddars
  • Wisconsin Beer Cheddar
  • Buffalo Wing Jack
  • Cherry Wine & Almond Cheddar Spreads
  • Colby & Colby Jack
  • Hickory Smoked Cheddar
  • Butter and Beer Kaese Cheeses
  • Bacon & Salami Processed Cheeses


Vern's

  • Regular & Smoked String
  • Party Cube Snack Pack


Widmer's

  • Wisconsin Mild Brick
  • Aged Brick Spread


Little Brown Cow

  • Aged Cheddar
  • Medium Cheddar

Sartori

  • Merlot Bellavitano
  • Black Pepper Bellavitano
  • Bellavitano Gold
  • Tennessee Whiskey Bellavitano
  • Rosemary Asiago
  • Espresso Bellavitano
  • Raspberry Bellavitano
  • Balsamic Bellavitano


Henning's

  • Regular & flavored Curds
  • Mozzarella Whips
  • Mild, Medium & Aged Cheddars
  • Mild & Aged Bricks
  • Pepper Jack
  • Colby & Colby Jack
  • Habanero Jack
  • Muenster
  • Onion & Chive Cheddar
  • Limburger
  • Havarti & Havarti with Dill
  • Swiss & Baby Swiss
  • Tomato Basil Cheddar
  • Chipotle Cheddar
  • Mango Fire Cheddar
  • Caraway Cheddar
  • Bacon Fest Cheddar


Gibbsville

  • Regular Curds
  • Mozzarella Whips
  • Regular String
  • Medium, Sharp, & Super Sharp Cheddars
  • Colby
  • Pepper Jack
  • Baby Swiss

Pine River Cheese Spreads

  • Port Wine
  • Sharp Cheddar
  • Mango Habanero
  • Swiss Almond
  • Pimento
  • Garlic & Herb
  • Horseradish
  • Cranberry Cheddar
  • Spicy Beer
  • Garden Vegetable
  • Toasted Onion
  • Smokey Bacon


Deer Creek

  • Vat 17 Cheddar
  • The Rattlesnake
  • 1, 3, 5, & 7 Year Cheddars
  • The Doe Cheddar
  • The Blue Jay
  • The Stag
  • The Night Walker
  • The Moonrabbit
  • The Fawn


Carr Valley

  • Budweiser Pubb Cheddar Spread
  • Sharp Cheddar Spread
  • Spicy Beer Spread
  • Garlic Cheddar Spread
  • Boozin Ewe Wedge
  • Various Bread Cheeses
Pig
Cow

Ask the Butcher